Page 15 of 25

Re: Iron Horse! 2.20.0 Released 5th April 2021

Posted: 09 Apr 2021 21:58
by LaChupacabra
Short conclusion after a short test: Restaurant car pays off to add to each long train. The best results will still be seen on short journeys where maintenance costs play a greater role than on long journeys.

But, if the loading time of this wagon would be significantly longer, it would be uneconomic on short journeys and still worth using on long journeys.
Personally, I prefer the cargo aging effect, but such a solution would also make sense. :) In the case of luxury and large-capacity wagons, it would be enough that they would have different speeds and loading time. The variety of wagons available is always nice. ; )

Re: Iron Horse! 2.20.0 Released 5th April 2021

Posted: 10 Apr 2021 12:29
by andythenorth
Another test version. This one removes all pax and mail vehicles, and the associated express engines, railcars etc (about 80 of these deleted). Express freight cars also removed.

Tech tree here: https://grf.farm/iron-horse/freight-onl ... e_red.html
iron-horse-2.22.0-27-g831194eb.tar
(17.63 MiB) Downloaded 150 times

Re: Iron Horse! 2.20.0 Released 5th April 2021

Posted: 10 Apr 2021 13:30
by Mikkamakka
andythenorth wrote: 10 Apr 2021 12:29 This one removes all pax and mail vehicles, and the associated express engines, railcars etc (about 80 of these deleted). Express freight cars also removed.
What is the problem with express freight?
Anyway, just starting a game with the prev test version. I really like the idea of slower suburban coaches.

Re: Iron Horse! 2.20.0 Released 5th April 2021

Posted: 12 Apr 2021 10:25
by andythenorth
Another test. This one:
  • Keeps all the pax and express freight vehicles
  • Set cargo aging to default OpenTTD value for high capacity pax vehicles (metro, suburban)
iron-horse-2.22.0-30-gd7db03bc.tar
(22.77 MiB) Downloaded 151 times
After a lot of testing, I'm convinced that cargo aging is better left at default value. Changing it introduces multiple problems, which mean it isn't a useful balancing parameter for vehicles.

This is obviously my view, other sets can take a different view etc etc. :)

Also I want to say that it is good to try out experiments in the newgrf spec, I would rather test whether things are useful than debate forever if we are allowed to add a new var or property :)

Please don't interpret my comments as regret that the property was even introduced, we often can't know what's good in the grf API until it's been tried by authors. No omelette without broken eggs etc.

Anyway, all that said...

Using the attached grf it's trivial to demonstrate that metro is very over-powered due to high capacity, and will earn substantially more than faster trains on some intercity routes, despite being slow. Similarly suburban trains are over-powered on intercity routes relative to the faster trains.

These aren't guaranteed results for all possible routes, but they are easily achieved.

There are no balancing factors currently that can reliably avoid this. :twisted:

I'm in favour of funny or useful exploits, but I would rather eliminate this one as it means the Iron Horse design of 'best train for specific role' is fundamentally broken.

But eh, can't do anything about that in current spec, so it is what it is. If you don't like OP intercity metro trains, don't use them :twisted:

I think shipping this would be better than removing all the pax stuff, which would be a more pure solution, but might look like pointless dummy-spitting vandalism :P

Re: Iron Horse! 2.23.0 Released 12th April 2021

Posted: 12 Apr 2021 14:09
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.23.0 now on Bananas!

Not going to lie, these last few releases are no fun and all grind.

I've decided not to delete a big chunk of the grf because I think it would look like petty vandalism, but there was no joy in this release at all :twisted:

--

Trying to balance vehicles in a grf is a good idea.

Trying to balance vehicles in a grf to impose specific ideas about profitability is a really really really really bad idea (in the current spec).

--

To expand a little: the goal of Iron Horse is to mostly level vehicles, so that the choice of vehicle is mostly 'which vehicle looks nice' :D

There's a few details around intended role, and power, but mostly it's 'choose what looks nice'. Everything else will come out about the same, on average, across enough journeys.

--

This doesn't quite work for pax transport, because cdist in cities imposes a requirement for pax vehicles with very high capacity.

But vehicles with smaller capacity are more pleasing on some routes outside cities.

--

There's no way in the current spec to level these vehicles according to journey time or route length.

The outcome is that the higher capacity vehicles will be OP on many many routes, we'll just have to live with that :twisted:

--

I'm going to ignore any further feedback about relative profitability balance.

This silly adventure has left me a day or so away from deleting the project, which isn't what I want to do at all :roll:

So for sanity, I'm going to not pay attention to further requests about cargo aging etc

--

Thanks all, especially those who provided feedback. :bow: I've been a pain-in-the-arse to a bunch of people in irc and discord for the last 2 weeks.

On the upside I've learnt a lot of detail about various game mechanics. :twisted:

--

2.23.0 Release

Changes
  • rebalanced Passenger Coaches to have lower capacity
  • added Suburban Coaches with high capacity
    • speeds match railcars
    • Suburban Coaches use the alternative coach livery to make them visually distinct from Passenger Coaches
    • the livery can be toggled to match standard Passenger Coaches by depot flip (ctrl-click on the vehicle in depot)
    • Suburban Coaches will be hidden in simplified gameplay mode
  • the following railcars now have 'Suburban High Capacity' as role, and have increased capacity
    • Deasil, Slammer, Tin Rocket, Happy Train
    • Athena, Geronimo, Breeze, Zeus
  • minor tweaks to narrow gauge passenger vehicle capacities
  • reintroduced Restaurant Cars
    • adding a Restaurant Car to a train will provide a bonus: eliminates the running cost for all Passenger Coaches in the train
  • reduced running costs of some higher speed passenger vehicles for game balance
  • show the role in buy menu for all types of passenger vehicle
Codechanges
  • removed all code relating to cargo age period, this is now at the default 185 value for all Iron Horse vehicles
  • unified some methods relating to passenger car capacity and loading speed
  • split railbus classes out from railcar classes
Translations
  • translation updates (thanks translators)

Re: Iron Horse! 2.24.0 Released 15th April 2021

Posted: 15 Apr 2021 07:17
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.24.0 now on Bananas ;)

This one was more fun. Adds Pacers :twisted:

Docs: https://grf.farm/iron-horse/2.24.0/index.html

-------------
2.24.0 Release
-------------

"The world would not make a racehorse of a donkey." - proverb

Changes
  • added 3 railbuses
    • Clipper, 180hp, 31 passengers, available around 1956
    • Skipper, 225hp, 36 passengers, available around 1986
    • Zipper, 280hp, 36 passengers, available around 2016
  • minor run-cost tweaks to railcars to balance against railbuses
Translations
  • translation updates (thanks translators)
clipper.png
clipper.png (52.37 KiB) Viewed 11236 times
skippper.png
skippper.png (44.81 KiB) Viewed 11236 times
zipper.png
zipper.png (48.85 KiB) Viewed 11236 times

Re: Iron Horse! 2.24.0 Released 15th April 2021

Posted: 15 Apr 2021 07:26
by andythenorth
Goes it railbus with van. 1 tile. Ultimate train?

clippers_van.png
clippers_van.png (12.46 KiB) Viewed 11223 times

Re: Iron Horse! 2.25.0 Released 16th April 2021

Posted: 16 Apr 2021 17:54
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.25.0 now on Bananas :)

Docs: https://grf.farm/iron-horse/2.25.0/html ... arted.html

2.25.0 Release

Changes
  • provide earlier (available 1860) versions for some wagons
    • Mineral Wagon
    • Hopper
    • Ore Hopper
Fixes
  • railbuses should not be available in simplified gameplay

Re: Iron Horse! 2.26.0 Released 17th April 2021

Posted: 17 Apr 2021 13:33
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.26.0 now on Bananas.

Docs: https://grf.farm/iron-horse/2.26.0/html ... arted.html

-------------
2.26.0 Release
-------------

Changes
  • better electrified railtype compatibility for electro-diesel (bi-mode) vehicles
    • these vehicles should now use 'electrified' power and visual effects on a wider range of electrified railtypes
    • previously they only worked correctly for railtypes with 'ELRL' label
    • requires OpenTTD 1.11.0 or newer
    • tested as working with NuTracks 2
Fixes
  • electro-diesel (bi-mode) railcars now show power on diesel in buy menu, not power on electric, consistent with other bi-mode vehicles

Re: Iron Horse! 2.26.0 Released 17th April 2021

Posted: 18 Apr 2021 21:06
by arikover
andythenorth wrote: 17 Apr 2021 13:33
  • tested as working with NuTracks 2
Tested, ans also works with U&ReRMM 2.

andythenorth wrote: 15 Apr 2021 07:17 ...Adds Pacers :twisted:
I really like those!


Thank you!

Re: Iron Horse! 2.26.0 Released 17th April 2021

Posted: 19 Apr 2021 11:38
by andythenorth
arikover wrote: 18 Apr 2021 21:06 Tested, ans also works with U&ReRMM 2.
Thanks, that's helpful :)

Re: Iron Horse! 2.26.0 Released 17th April 2021

Posted: 23 Apr 2021 14:43
by Mikkamakka
Not sure if this is a bug or i've missed something, but it looks like wrong sprite. :)

Image

Re: Iron Horse! 2.26.0 Released 17th April 2021

Posted: 23 Apr 2021 15:56
by andythenorth
Mikkamakka wrote: 23 Apr 2021 14:43 Not sure if this is a bug or i've missed something, but it looks like wrong sprite. :)
Ha ha yes. I have fixed this and will do a release soon :D

Re: Iron Horse! 2.26.0 Released 17th April 2021

Posted: 16 May 2021 00:40
by 2TallTyler
I have some near-duplicate wagons in 2.26, including the Dump Car and Ore Hopper. All that's different is the running cost. Is one the discount model? :P

Re: Iron Horse trains - releases

Posted: 06 Aug 2021 03:43
by Maddog45353
More updates planned?

Re: Iron Horse trains - releases

Posted: 12 Sep 2021 11:49
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.27.0 now on Bananas.

2.27.0 Release

Changes
  • adjusted narrow gauge engine roster
    • added Thor, Gargouille and Maximillian as larger narrow gauge engines, with a little more power than the smaller engines
    • adjusted stats of Cheese Bug, Bean Feast, Pikel and Boar Cat to differentiate from the larger engines
  • added wagons
    • Potash Hoppers (refit potash only)
    • narrow gauge Bolster Wagons
    • narrow gauge Covered Hoppers
    • narrow gauge Cryo Tankers
    • narrow cauge Ore Hoppers
    • narrow gauge small Brake Van
  • renamed Timber Wagon to Log Carrier as the cargo it carries is 'logs in FIRS', 'timber' being a different cargo
  • reduced capacity of Edibles Tanker and Refrigerated Van to reflect higher speeds (now matches Expess Vans)
  • sprite support for sugarcane cargo (2TallTyler)
Fixes
  • door sprites were wrong in | view for gen 5D and 6D sliding wall vans
  • pixels were missing for Snapper, Mumble, and narrow gauge railcar trailers
  • gen 2 mineral wagons, hoppers and ore hoppers weren't supposed to be included, as gen 1 and 2 stats overlap for these wagons
Docs
  • (fix) sprites were misaligned in Train Whack mini-game
horse-2-27-0-3.png
horse-2-27-0-3.png (85.56 KiB) Viewed 8900 times
horse-2-27-0-1.png
horse-2-27-0-1.png (46.99 KiB) Viewed 8907 times
horse-2-27-0-2.png
horse-2-27-0-2.png (34.1 KiB) Viewed 8906 times

Re: Iron Horse trains - releases

Posted: 03 Oct 2021 09:58
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.28.0 release

2.28.0 Release

Changes
  • added freight engines
    • Mainstay steam heavy freight engine, 1850 hp, available around 1930
    • Yillen diesel heavy freight engine, 2200 hp, available around 1958
  • added wagons
    • narrow gauge Skips (low speed side-tipping wagons)
    • Acid Tankers (general liquids)
    • Pressure Tankers (gas cargos)
  • adjusted Cryo Tankers
    • reworked sprites to be fatter appearance
    • gen 3 and narrow gauge Cryo Tankers replaced by equivalent Pressure Tankers
  • sprite support for peat cargo
Fixes
  • many intermodal wagons may have had incorrect sprites for platform height (most default wagons were probably using incorrect low_floor variant)
  • remove extraneous pixels from \ view of Blind Smuir
Codechanges
  • prevent rendered spritesheets being created more than once, avoiding problems where pool workers are deleting files in use by another pool worker
  • coil buggies and ingot cars referenced a non-existent chassis sprite (didn't error as chassis sprite isn't used, but should still be defined)
horse-2-28-0-1.png
horse-2-28-0-1.png (30.33 KiB) Viewed 8232 times
horse-2-28-0-2.png
horse-2-28-0-2.png (26.43 KiB) Viewed 8232 times
horse-2-28-0-3.png
horse-2-28-0-3.png (24.31 KiB) Viewed 8232 times

Re: Iron Horse trains - releases

Posted: 06 Oct 2021 13:19
by andythenorth
Iron Horse 2.29.0 now on bananas


2.29.0 Release

Iron Horse 2.29.0 is savegame compatible with previous Iron Horse versions, but any existing Merlion engines in savegames will change name and appearance.

Changes
  • reshuffled some gen 4 diesel engines
    • Merlion is now a freight engine, equivalent and alternative to the Growler, 1750hp, available around 1958
    • added Daring general purpose / express engine, same role as Merlion previously filled, 1750hp, available around 1961
    • added Withershins heavy freight engine, equivalent and alternative to the Chinook, 2900hp, available around 1960
    • Intrepid sprites now inspired by 'banger blue' BR class 47
  • improved chassis pixels for Kelpie and Griffon
*Fixes
  • set correct weight for all Shoeboxes
Docs
  • added space between value and unit for 'hp' and 'mph' values

Re: Iron Horse trains - releases

Posted: 23 Oct 2021 10:11
by andythenorth
2.30.0 Release

Iron Horse 2.30.0 is possibly savegame compatible with previous Iron Horse versions, but some existing mineral wagons might change name and appearance. YOLO.

Changes
  • reshuffled some general purpose / express engines
    • 4-6-4 Streamer is now super-heavy class, equivalent and alternative to 2-8-2 Pegasus, 2200 hp, available around 1934
    • add 2-6-2 Arrow general purpose / express engine, equivalent and alternative to 4-6-0 Strongbow, 1900 hp, available around 1934
    • added Tenacious general purpose / express engine, equivalent and alternative to the Wyvern / Intrepid, 2150 hp, available around 1960
    • tweaked Dragon sprites to ensure they're distinct from Tenacious
    • switched Resilient alternative livery to one inspired by Freightliner/GBRF
  • removed expiry from Yillen, it's a useful size and looks nice for slower industrial lines (e.g. steelworks) even when obsolete for other uses
  • adjusted mineral (bulk cargo) wagons
    • added Ore Dump Wagons, mostly based on rotary tipplers
    • added Aggregates Wagons
    • added MGR Hoppers (available gen 4 and 5 only)
    • adjusted sprites for Hoppers, to differentiate from MGR Hoppers
    • improved sprites for High Side Mineral Wagons
Docs
  • split freight and express 'heavy' roles into 'heavy' and 'super-heavy'
  • (fix) Chuggypig replaces Lamia, not Gronk in tech tree view
Translations
  • translation updates (thanks translators)
horse-2-30-0-1.png
horse-2-30-0-1.png (76.2 KiB) Viewed 7700 times
horse-2-30-0-2.png
horse-2-30-0-2.png (95.56 KiB) Viewed 7698 times
horse-2-30-0-3.png
horse-2-30-0-3.png (103.68 KiB) Viewed 7698 times

Re: Iron Horse trains - releases

Posted: 02 Nov 2021 17:42
by Thrillville109
Is the North American set still in the pipeline?