Page 10 of 22
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 15:58
by Voyager One
A-ha, so the game's code for trams itself prevents separate buying for engines and wagons? I didn't know that.
Even better, no messing around.
EDIT:
The
tracking table has been slightly modified. I've split pax and cargo tram(sets).
Also,
IMPORTANT, I've started compiling the cargo's list wrt done trams. Please take a look and comment if you find anything weird.
You will also notice that we have absolutely no trams for liquid cargoes, I will see that I find some to include, I've seen some during my browsing.
And in the meantime:

- Hellingly Whiteley Tram.PNG (13.87 KiB) Viewed 4101 times
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 18:26
by doxlulzem
Nice to see more UK trams! And Voyager, you're such a machine that Gmail has started sending the TT-Forums 'new post' emails to spam

Keep up the good work, can't wait for the NewGRF
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 18:35
by Voyager One
doxlulzem wrote:Gmail has started sending the TT-Forums 'new post' emails to spam
Hahahaha, I'd better watch for Owen's wrath then.
doxlulzem wrote:Keep up the good work, can't wait for the NewGRF
Me too!
BTW people, I've forgotten to explain something regarding those cargoes.
E.g. coal, ore, grain... could be (and were) transported in e.g. bags...
E.g. oil, water and other liquids could be (and were) transported in e.g. barrels...
E.g. steel items, wood items... could be (and were) transported in e.g. crates...
Think a bit unorthodoxly. Trams didn't have that many transport options like train and we need to improvise a bit. As for those trams in the list, I've tried using common sense, e.g. an Express Parcels trams would carry goods and valuables but not e.g. bags of coal, even if it actually could carry them.
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 18:44
by doxlulzem
I suppose it was easier that way, especially for interurban freight.
Say a brewery had a tram route through a city to a big shop - why have the cost of big expensive liquid pumps on both ends when you can put it in kegs that go straight to the shelves?
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 19:17
by andythenorth
You can invent trams like Road Hog is, but maybe that's not the goal?
You can at least have the grain trams
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vippetangen_Line
And if you search "Differential Steel Car Company Interurban" you'll find stuff.
http://donsdepot.donrossgroup.net/dr1005/cts0518.jpg
http://www.shorelinetrolley.com/stm/upl ... 3&0156.jpg
http://donsdepot.donrossgroup.net/dr0202/sre109.jpg
Interurbans are street-running trams, there's a load of oddities there if you want realisms.
Also not a tram, but a tram really
http://manxelectricrailway.co.uk/featur ... livestock/
This stuff is in Road Hog mind, so depends how overlapping you want to be

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 19:40
by Voyager One
Thank Andy, I'll take a serius look at your suggestions, they seem very nice. The grain tram is already in (Oslo Type S) and we already have a Manx freighter but...
andythenorth wrote:This stuff is in Road Hog mind, so depends how overlapping you want to be
This depends on how RL-based is Road Hog.

We're aiming to have trams as real as possible, based on RL history. Yes, there will be tweaking here and there but some historic basis will have to exist.
doxlulzem wrote:Say a brewery had a tram route through a city to a big shop
And speaking of that, you've reminded me, I must check because I think I've added a brewery tram but I can't remember which one right now.
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 20:45
by andythenorth
Voyager One wrote:This depends on how RL-based is Road Hog.

"Inspired by" for Road Hog. I do look for pictures of real stuff to get an idea of what to draw, but I pay no mind to the stats, dates etc.

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 22 Oct 2014 21:09
by ISA
andythenorth wrote:I do look for pictures of real stuff to get an idea of what to draw

+1 do that... I do that all the things what I draw, but the judgement is left for the users/lookers how real they look!

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 23 Oct 2014 06:06
by Voyager One
andythenorth wrote:Voyager One wrote:This depends on how RL-based is Road Hog.

"Inspired by" for Road Hog. I do look for pictures of real stuff to get an idea of what to draw, but I pay no mind to the stats, dates etc.

Then the overlap will be marginal. I try to be as historically accurate as possible although it's not absolutely possible due to severe lack of information on many many freight trams. Finding pictures is rather easy, stats are often not present, apart from some years.
Regardless of the overlap, I think these two sets will be nicely compatible.
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 23 Oct 2014 16:12
by Voyager One

- Alexandra Timber Tram.PNG (15.1 KiB) Viewed 3961 times

- Prague Stresovice Cargo Tram.PNG (14.01 KiB) Viewed 3961 times
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 24 Oct 2014 17:41
by Voyager One
Good news! The Dacia Sandero... Oh wait, this isn't Top Gear.

Let's restart this...
Good news! We will now have all cargoes covered!
I've managed to find appropriate trams for all standard cargoes, including some very eluding liquid-carrying trams. In reality, these were used as street cleaning vehicles but hey... nothing is perfect, isn't it?

They'll do just fine in our set!
FIRS, ECS and similar stuff will eventually be supported as well.
(unless Foo decides he's tired of us

)
So, you can check all these in our
tracking table. And as always, additional suggestions are more than welcome!
And in the meantime, 3 new trams! In case you're wondering what's that orange cargo, well, it's a nice way to have all appropriate cargoes by recoloring them via code. Once again, all hail Foobar!

- New York Bulk Freight Car.PNG (11.8 KiB) Viewed 3888 times

- Esch-sur-Alzette AEG U28 Mining Tram.PNG (15.55 KiB) Viewed 3888 times

- Bernburg Mine Lew EL3.PNG (16.53 KiB) Viewed 3888 times
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 24 Oct 2014 18:45
by te_lanus
What About Trolly Busses?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rmX8rS-kg6U (some in South Africa From 1973)
and here is a Tram with Awesome
Horse Power
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 24 Oct 2014 20:42
by Voyager One
Trolley buses no, this is a tram set. Maybe we will consider making a separate trolleybus set but here no.
As for horse-drawn tram, I'm afraid that's another no, at least for now. There are several reasons why not but the main one is that hey would be completely useless refarding gameplay because of their extremely low speed and capacity. Still, that's a no at this moment.

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 24 Oct 2014 21:48
by doxlulzem
Great to see some single-cargo trams and some longer trains. Is it even possible to code trollybus catenaries into OpenTTD? I know next to nothing about code, less about NML and such but can you have tram rails, and pantographs separate, like in Locomotion?
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 24 Oct 2014 22:28
by kamnet
Voyager One wrote:Trolley buses no, this is a tram set. Maybe we will consider making a separate trolleybus set but here no.
Count me in on a future trolley bus set. I've also previously talked with Foobar about a possible kerb-guided bus set as well. Of course, that set is probably going to be way smaller.
Voyager One wrote:As for horse-drawn tram, I'm afraid that's another no, at least for now. There are several reasons why not but the main one is that hey would be completely useless refarding gameplay because of their extremely low speed and capacity. Still, that's a no at this moment.

Completely useless? Strange, as that's actually the bulk of my last game, where I profited handsomely. Properly implemented and managed I've quadruped the size of my main cities by providing good service with horses in eGRVTS. The trams, though, aren't as profitable even though in real life they completely eliminated much of the omnibus carriage and cartage service in urban areas. Again, this is going to be a way smaller set since there's really only so many styles and capacities of wagons you can make, and horses didn't get significantly faster or stronger in the roughly two centuries that they reached their height of utility.
doxlulzem wrote:Great to see some single-cargo trams and some longer trains. Is it even possible to code trollybus catenaries into OpenTTD? I know next to nothing about code, less about NML and such but can you have tram rails, and pantographs separate, like in Locomotion?
Yep, there's already a
trolleybus set that replaces trams and implements its own overhead wires.
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 25 Oct 2014 12:46
by ssmit132
Voyager One wrote:Good news! The Dacia Sandero... Oh wait, this isn't Top Gear.

Let's restart this...

Good to see someone else likes that Top Gear gag.
Anyway, definitely looking forward to both this and 2CC|Trains being done. I'm happy that Australia has plenty of representation in this as well.

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 25 Oct 2014 13:46
by ISA
Voyager One wrote:Good news! We will now have all cargoes covered!
All will be covered hoppers?

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 25 Oct 2014 16:53
by Voyager One
ISA wrote:Voyager One wrote:Good news! We will now have all cargoes covered!
All will be covered coppers?

Ah no!

I've meant that all cargoes and cargo classes will be available trough refits, I've managed to find appropriate or approximate trams for all. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 26 Oct 2014 18:16
by Voyager One
Re: [OTTD] 2CC|Trams - Development Discussion
Posted: 26 Oct 2014 18:17
by Voyager One

- Kiso Logging Tram.PNG (14.33 KiB) Viewed 3668 times

- St. Gallen Xe 2-2 Tanker Tram.PNG (12.22 KiB) Viewed 3668 times

- Kaliningrad Tatra T4 Tanker Tram.PNG (13.14 KiB) Viewed 3668 times