Page 1 of 1
Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 30 Aug 2010 03:58
by Tattoo
I read recently that someone, don't remember who, changed the limit to the dimension size of an image being posted but it didn't say what the new size is. I posted images before from my widescreen but now they show up as links and not the image. So can someone tell me what the dimension size limit is now? Thanks...
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 30 Aug 2010 04:47
by Nite Owl
800 x 600
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 30 Aug 2010 17:08
by Tattoo
Thanks Night Owl. I'll try it and see.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 30 Aug 2010 17:38
by orudge
Nite Owl is correct with regards to the dimensions. 800x600 has always been the limit (well, for the past few years anyway), but for a while larger images were scaled down. However, with screenshots this often resulted in a much larger filesize, so this feature was disabled.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 04:35
by Tattoo
Oh ok. Thanks, orudge. I'll just have to resize them before I post em now.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 12:25
by orudge
They will still show as links, of course, if they're larger than the permitted dimensions.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 16:49
by Lord Aro
since 1024 x 768 is much more normal nowadays (and 800 x 600 is much rarer), how about an increase?

Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 17:26
by Rubidium
Lord Aro wrote:since 1024 x 768 is much more normal nowadays (and 800 x 600 is much rarer), how about an increase?
Please not. I dislike websites that require me to basically full-screen my browser to normally read a thread.
The main problem with that is that it becomes 1900 pixels wide and everything scales with that, so I've got lines of text of like 1700 pixels which becomes really hard to read; try reading normally printed text spread over the width of a page of A3 instead of the normal book B5/A5 or at least multiple columns on A4.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 17:59
by orudge
Lord Aro wrote:since 1024 x 768 is much more normal nowadays (and 800 x 600 is much rarer), how about an increase?

This was considered relatively recently, but so far I've decided against it.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 18:01
by Lord Aro
Lord Aro wrote:since 1024 x 768 is much more normal nowadays (and 800 x 600 is much rarer), how about an increase?
Rubidium wrote:Please not. I dislike websites that require me to basically full-screen my browser to normally read a thread.
The main problem with that is that it becomes 1900 pixels wide and everything scales with that, so I've got lines of text of like 1700 pixels which becomes really hard to read; try reading normally printed text spread over the width of a page of A3 instead of the normal book B5/A5 or at least multiple columns on A4.
orudge wrote:
This was considered relatively recently, but so far I've decided against it.
ok then, ignore me

Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 18:27
by Tattoo
orudge wrote:They will still show as links, of course, if they're larger than the permitted dimensions.
Yes, I understand but I have a 24" widescreen so I'll have to crop and resize either way if I want them to show up without a link. I like how it was before where the image was resized by the forum but I guess I'll make do with how it is now. Thanks...
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 19:14
by orudge
Tattoo wrote:Yes, I understand but I have a 24" widescreen so I'll have to crop and resize either way if I want them to show up without a link. I like how it was before where the image was resized by the forum but I guess I'll make do with how it is now. Thanks...
Alas, phpBB resized screenshots into smaller but smoothed .png files, which sometimes resulted in massive files (say, over a megabyte for a file that was originally 200KB).
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 19:22
by lawton27
Lord Aro wrote:since 1024 x 768 is much more normal nowadays (and 800 x 600 is much rarer), how about an increase?

Not that I'd argue either way here's some statistics I've gathered from my website, although this is not necessarily representative of tt-forums users, orudge perhaps you should consider getting google analytics for the forums to gather data such as this.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 19:33
by Lord Aro
Lord Aro wrote:
ok then, ignore me

and i used the wrong word; i meant: minimum
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 31 Aug 2010 20:41
by orudge
lawton27 wrote:Not that I'd argue either way here's some statistics I've gathered from my website, although this is not necessarily representative of tt-forums users, orudge perhaps you should consider getting google analytics for the forums to gather data such as this.
I did a little poll not so long ago. While many people do have larger screens now, not everyone (as Rubidium says) uses their browser in a full screen mode. Plus, there are an increasing number of people accessing the forums from mobile devices now, which do, of course, have small screens. As such, I think adding huge graphics to the forums in-line would not really be the best thing at the moment.
Now, a user-customisable option, on the other hand, might be good. But alas, phpBB doesn't support it.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 01 Sep 2010 00:42
by Tattoo
orudge wrote:Tattoo wrote:Yes, I understand but I have a 24" widescreen so I'll have to crop and resize either way if I want them to show up without a link. I like how it was before where the image was resized by the forum but I guess I'll make do with how it is now. Thanks...
Alas, phpBB resized screenshots into smaller but smoothed .png files, which sometimes resulted in massive files (say, over a megabyte for a file that was originally 200KB).
WOW! the size increases that much the way it was before? That is a lot. So because it gets shrunk, does it save a NEW shrunk file AND the original?
orudge wrote:I did a little poll not so long ago. While many people do have larger screens now, not everyone (as Rubidium says) uses their browser in a full screen mode. Plus, there are an increasing number of people accessing the forums from mobile devices now, which do, of course, have small screens. As such, I think adding huge graphics to the forums in-line would not really be the best thing at the moment.
Now, a user-customisable option, on the other hand, might be good. But alas, phpBB doesn't support it.
I don't use my browser full screen either and that's cool that you're thinking about these ppl too. Ya gotta be versatile now a days, right...
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 01 Sep 2010 00:51
by orudge
Tattoo wrote:WOW! the size increases that much the way it was before?
Sometimes, not always. TTD screenshots were particularly bad, because they're typically just 8-bit paletted PNGs, which compress quite well, but phpBB's resizing mechanism would smooth them out, which ends up using significantly more colours, and is less compressible. Hence, the thumbnail file has a larger filesize.
Re: Want to know the demension size limit of an image to post
Posted: 01 Sep 2010 01:12
by Tattoo
Oh, ok. Now I understand how it works. Thanks