Page 1 of 2
Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 16 Oct 2009 10:58
by Brianetta
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-p ... 310051.stm
Minor injuries only, although seeing the mother's reaction can be uncomfortable.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 16 Oct 2009 19:02
by 61653
Just saw that on C4 news, almost pretty grim...
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 18 Oct 2009 22:57
by noofnoof
yeah, I saw that on my local news, nasty stuff. don't mess with trains.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 08:43
by Nawdic
i found it to be a bit funny...
i know its wrong, but anyway...
*chuckles in background*

Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 08:45
by Kevo00
tommietomato wrote:i found it to be a bit funny...
i know its wrong, but anyway...
*chuckles in background*

*puts on tin hat*
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 08:48
by Nawdic
To be honest, I have no idea what you are on about...
At least i am not the only one who thought it was funny, my dad laughed at it as well.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 13:41
by Niek
I don't see how that is funny in any way.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 15:47
by Dave
Kevo00 wrote:tommietomato wrote:i found it to be a bit funny...
i know its wrong, but anyway...
*chuckles in background*

*puts on tin hat*
You might well put that tinhat on lad.
I'm sorry tommie, but there's nothing funny about what could have been a terrible, terrible accident.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 16:55
by 61653
Dave Worley wrote:Kevo00 wrote:tommietomato wrote:i found it to be a bit funny...
i know its wrong, but anyway...
*chuckles in background*

*puts on tin hat*
You might well put that tinhat on lad.
I'm sorry tommie, but there's nothing funny about what
could have been a terrible, terrible accident.
but seeing as the kid was ok, lulz away...
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 20:24
by Chrill
All I feel when I see this is fear, basically. I imagine the thoughts running through the mother's head as she sees her baby fall down on the tracks and sees the train plow straight over the spot. It's just unimaginable what she feels as that point, and it makes me feel really uncomfortable. I am extremely happy to know that the baby was just fine after this
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 21:24
by Ameecher
Dave Worley wrote:I'm sorry tommie, but there's nothing funny about what could have been a terrible, terrible accident.
A generation raised by You've been framed

Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 21:28
by Chrill
Ameecher wrote:Dave Worley wrote:I'm sorry tommie, but there's nothing funny about what could have been a terrible, terrible accident.
A generation raised by You've been framed

There's a difference between pain and suspected death. This video basically shouts "The baby just died", while in shows like You've been framed or "America's Funniest Home Videos", it's most often quite obvious that it was a silly accident with no large repercussions. Those shows never feature videos as emotional and serious as these, and to contribute to making it fun, they present it in a silly manner
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 22:35
by Kevo00
Well, I just can't believe he thinks that was funny.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 19 Oct 2009 23:31
by noofnoof
I'll watch it over and over again, not because it's funny, but because I get such a rush.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 20 Oct 2009 23:52
by Redirect Left
I saw that on the news too, i'm frankly amazed the baby got away apparantly "virtually unharmed" according to the news report. Amazing.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 21 Oct 2009 10:12
by John
I've heard that that was because the baby was strapped into the buggy and the buggy got caught on the front of the train.
The only injury was a minor bump to the head.
It raises some interesting questions about station design. Having the edge lower then the middle is great for rainwater run off, but you would have thought the reverse would have been safer (so things role towards the middle of the station).
I know the height of the platform edge is dictated, but does anyone know if the profile of the station is (either in Australia or anywhere else?)
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 21 Oct 2009 19:31
by Ameecher
Well modern stations have quite a lot dictated, as for actual rules I don't know but certainly most new platforms that I have stood at have a culvert at the back of the platform with a slight angle to the platform so that rainwater drains away from the tracks to the back of the platform, obviously though, not all platforms are brand spanking new...
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 21 Oct 2009 21:22
by Kevo00
Also in Aus, any culvert can be very quickly overwhelmed by extreme rainstorms, so draining forwards onto the track might make sense.
I may be corrected by the Aussies on this board, and I've never been to Victoria, but where I have been in NSW I gained the impression that railways tend to be somewhat ad hoc in Aus, and that individual stations can vary a lot, with no consistent standard applied. Take a look for instance at Scone's 'relatively' narrow platform
http://www.nswrail.net/locations/photo. ... SW:Scone:2, Macdonaldtown's tiles which might use a little TLC
http://www.nswrail.net/locations/photo. ... in_south:0 or Broadmeadow's relatively substantial ones
http://www.nswrail.net/locations/photo. ... admeadow:5.
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 09 Nov 2009 14:27
by Illegal_Alien
Well, we got a metrostation here who has a sloped platform, but its also a bit sloped away from the track, so you cant go on the tracks when racing down the platform:

(Looking down, see the blue line who gives out the NAP.)
Re: Baby under caught on CCTV
Posted: 09 Nov 2009 23:11
by audigex
Even though I already knew the baby would be fine, I still nearly died with fright. I can't even imagine what that poor mother must have felt for that split second.
It's bad enough when you lose track of a toddler for a split second, but to actually see the train plough into the pushchair... jesus.
Don't be too harsh on the laugher, it does have some comic value in the moment between the pushchair rolling and the train appearing, and we do know the baby's okay beforehand.