Page 3 of 3

Posted: 15 Oct 2006 22:44
by Bjarni
Darkvater wrote:
XeryusTC wrote:I don't really associate sheep with cloning. I associate them with wool, and I don't think you can get trains made of wool...
I think the classic 2 trains still works best.
So you are willing to have the train-icon for cloning aircraft? Doesn't that look a bit odd to say the least?
That's why I will go for one sprite for each vehicle type (ok 2 including the mouse pointers)

Posted: 15 Oct 2006 23:36
by Born Acorn
I myself find
Image

To be the most fitting in design so far.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 06:22
by XeryusTC
Darkvater wrote:
XeryusTC wrote:I don't really associate sheep with cloning. I associate them with wool, and I don't think you can get trains made of wool...
I think the classic 2 trains still works best.
So you are willing to have the train-icon for cloning aircraft? Doesn't that look a bit odd to say the least?

I don't know where you guys live but sheep are synonymous with cloning (Dolly anyone?) Especially if you see two identical sheep somewhere. We can discuss if these icons fit with the game, but not if sheep==cloning because that is a fact.
That's not true, sheep are synonymous with wool for me.
I also doubt that you'll see a bull as geneticly altered (Herman), the same goes with sheep for me, I don't associate them with cloning. Period.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 07:01
by peter1138
I associate sheep with "following each other around" so maybe we should use sheep for Shared Orders?

No, I didn't think so either... :)

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 07:27
by WWTBAM
its either a special one for each, the sheep or the clipborad coppy one.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 10:16
by Brianetta
I associate sheep with mindlessly following the leader (much like peter1138 suggests), not cloning. Like Born Acorn, I much prefer the use of four graphics.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 11:07
by skidd13
After all that discussion I'd say let the sheep be sheep and get back to the concept of the 4 diffrent cloning icons!
Thats my point of view. :]

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 12:41
by richk67
Brianetta wrote:I associate sheep with mindlessly following the leader (much like peter1138 suggests), not cloning. Like Born Acorn, I much prefer the use of four graphics.
Im in the "it means cloning" camp. But I do agree; the four graphics would be clearer.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 22:25
by Darkvater
Ok, that's fine by me. Now the only question is if they should be as they are now, or be a golden/normal colour like we could see on some WIP's made by skidd? The golden signifying 'master copy'.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 23:41
by richk67
I like the pale shadow/ghost image behind the vehicle pic. It really says "another of these" to me. I think colour on the duplicate would just confuse it.

Posted: 16 Oct 2006 23:42
by Born Acorn
Yeah, I agree with richk67. They are also TTD style, and fit right in.

Posted: 17 Oct 2006 11:07
by skidd13
I agree with the others to use the gray/normal color.

Who is at work with the icons ATM?

Posted: 17 Oct 2006 11:53
by Darkvater
skidd13 wrote:I agree with the others to use the gray/normal color.

Who is at work with the icons ATM?
What do you mean skidd? If nothing changes I'll add these to openttd.grf tonight.

Posted: 17 Oct 2006 12:00
by Born Acorn
If we mean these:
Image

Then it looks like they are already done.

Posted: 17 Oct 2006 12:09
by skidd13
Darkvater wrote:What do you mean skidd? If nothing changes I'll add these to openttd.grf tonight.
I thought that animated cursors are @WIP. If not, Ok than thats it.

@Darkvater:
And please renew the previous added icons with the newer ones (I adjusted them a bit to have the same alignment).

Posted: 18 Oct 2006 21:02
by Darkvater
skidd13 wrote:
Darkvater wrote:What do you mean skidd? If nothing changes I'll add these to openttd.grf tonight.
I thought that animated cursors are @WIP. If not, Ok than thats it.

@Darkvater:
And please renew the previous added icons with the newer ones (I adjusted them a bit to have the same alignment).
Well it seems everyone else is fine with them, so if you are as well I can consider them done. To me they look perfect :)

Posted: 18 Oct 2006 21:30
by skidd13
Darkvater wrote:Well it seems everyone else is fine with them, so if you are as well I can consider them done. To me they look perfect :)
Maybe I'm too nitpick, but I prefer that the icons (delete and upgrade) are exactly at the same position (even the few px). :lol:

So its your turn to decide.

Posted: 18 Oct 2006 21:59
by Darkvater
skidd13 wrote:
Darkvater wrote:Well it seems everyone else is fine with them, so if you are as well I can consider them done. To me they look perfect :)
Maybe I'm too nitpick, but I prefer that the icons (delete and upgrade) are exactly at the same position (even the few px). :lol:

So its your turn to decide.
I actually meant the clone buttons since I still haven't heard from bjarni about the autoreplace icons. He has been around though, but unable to pick one of your magnificient arrows. So unless you want to 'nitpick' :P on the clone buttons I'm good with them :).

I will update the depot buttons together with the autoreplace ones.

Posted: 24 Oct 2006 15:55
by Darkvater
Added clone buttons and an icon from MeusH at the start of the topic for shared orders. Good job people :D