Moderator: OpenTTD Developers
I played for 20 years game time or so, and then started doing airports after noticing my opponent did the same and was very dissapointed by the unproportional income from it.
I've played quite a bit of TTD over the years, and make very high profit trains which milk every cent out of a route, yet with 3 aircrafts I make 4-5 times than the total of my 15 trains.
(in my current game time I make about a million with each of the aircrafts
This is just crazy - I don't see how an aircraft can bring me 20 times more income than a train when it takes me half a minute to make the two airports and aircraft between them, compared to the time and planning needed for the train.
- Posts: 1395
- Joined: 12 Jun 2004 00:37
- Location: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
OTTD has some major balance issues (RVs are worthless. Ships too etc). For all the fancy new features that get added, I don't think anyone has ever bothered trying to fix them.
This is one of the main reasons I have planes disabled on my servers. It is way too easy to make an insane amount of money, where it takes some planning and work to do the same with trains.svartberg wrote:This is just crazy - I don't see how an aircraft can bring me 20 times more income than a train when it takes me half a minute to make the two airports and aircraft between them, compared to the time and planning needed for the train.
It may have not been "realistic", but it was very balanced unlike the current one.
I did some searching on the forums, but so far nothing.
It probably has something to do with feeder routes or cargodist, and the passengers ending up traveling net negative distance on some legs.wadeh wrote: ↑24 Sep 2020 17:56I have the exact opposite problem. All my aircraft consistently run a negative profit, and I keep getting the popup warnings that yearly profit for a particular aircraft was negative. However, when I get the yearly overview popup, my aircraft are somehow in the positive. How does that work?
Net negative distance probably needs an explanation: If you have three airports, A, B, and C, and you have a route from A to B, and one from B to C, but not one from A to C direct, then the only way to get from A to C is with a transfer at B. However, if C is actually closer to A than B is, then the relative distance from B to C when considering A the starting point is negative.
It can also perhaps involve the passengers traveling via some other, slower transport forms for part of their journey.
There may be several reasons for this:
- Too short connections (less than 200-300 tiles)
- Lack of interest in connection - planes often fly empty or slightly full
- Too high maintenance costs (may be affected by some newGRF settings)
- The above problems increase when the speed of planes is limited in the game settings
- Connecting connections into a transport network (eg AB + CD + AC) - in financial terms, this game doesn't encourage the construction of extensive networks. The problem is the ragged method of profit sharing, so that some vehicles in the supply chain may be assigned even very large losses, while others have huge and equally disproportionate profits. The way transport is assessed at stations also has an impact to some extent - the more connections you have, the more difficult it is to maintain high interest in your transport, which means that the number of travelers begins to decline. By adding another connection, you make the situation even worse...
Users browsing this forum: Google Adsense [Bot] and 9 guests