Multiplayer is a waste of time
Moderator: OpenTTD Developers
Multiplayer is a waste of time
I prefer to not have passwords in muliplayer, but for 3 times in a row, my company has fallen into stupid hands. Incidentally, today's user was "natasha bad girl". It's obvious there are a lot of idiots out there, there ought to be a way of banning them forever.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
Then show us a way of banning bad people in such a manner they can never join to a server.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
thats your own personal preference,
no password = company to be wrecked !!!
no password = company to be wrecked !!!
- White Rabbit
- Tycoon
- Posts: 1734
- Joined: 22 Jun 2005 19:15
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
I still refuse to set a password, even though it has cost me dearly before (my company has been ruined by the same person...a baron something...several times). It goes against my principles of an open doors company. I want everyone to enjoy (if they can ) what I build. It can be very fun and useful to have random people play with you. I strongly support and encourage non-passworded companies, and hope that you too can trust in the good nature of people (wow, it's like being against condoms and hoping for the best when you do it )
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
Some kind of registration system before being allowed in seems right, that way, it's easy to ban eejits.Rubidium wrote:Then show us a way of banning bad people in such a manner they can never join to a server.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
And how to stop people from registering a second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth,.... time and then trashing games again?bruce89 wrote:Some kind of registration system before being allowed in seems right, that way, it's easy to ban eejits.Rubidium wrote:Then show us a way of banning bad people in such a manner they can never join to a server.
You will only get a big database with nicknames that are banned and never used again.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
I set a password, but then I will give the password out to people who want it.
You can kind of tell whats going to happen when they join and immediately as for passwords, and also how they ask for passwords!
Also the reaction to saying ¨No¨ gives you a good idea.
Said no to one guy and he went ¨Mental¨. Fortunately I was the server so he got booted.... what was funny was he was trying to use an open door style argument to get me to let him in...... with added swear words!!
You can kind of tell whats going to happen when they join and immediately as for passwords, and also how they ask for passwords!
Also the reaction to saying ¨No¨ gives you a good idea.
Said no to one guy and he went ¨Mental¨. Fortunately I was the server so he got booted.... what was funny was he was trying to use an open door style argument to get me to let him in...... with added swear words!!
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
Have a period of a week where newly registered users can only make a new company or join a password protected company, I doubt wreckers would be willing to wait a week before destroying stuff. Wikipedia have a system like this, it means for 48 hours, users can't create new pages or edit "semi-protected"pages. This stops registrations just to spam, as people don't have the patience.Rubidium wrote:And how to stop people from registering a second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth,.... time and then trashing games again?
Ypu could even check the IP addressess of people registering, only allow an IP address to register once per day or somewthing.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
bruce89 wrote:I prefer to not have passwords in muliplayer, but for 3 times in a row, my company has fallen into stupid hands. Incidentally, today's user was "natasha bad girl". It's obvious there are a lot of idiots out there, there ought to be a way of banning them forever.
O my god !What a concidention !!!!I found out about OTTD last 2 days.I joined a server (i haven't set a password to my company, didn't know) and "natasha bad girl" joined it and removed all my stuff.)Then she was saying "I'm bad" and stuff like that.
Try to put password to your company , and i usually found good servers with nice people
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
You realise how annoying this would be to users that mean no harm, right? You *could* just use the excellent "retard-protection" thats already built into the game instead of asking for more.bruce89 wrote:Have a period of a week where newly registered users can only make a new company or join a password protected company, I doubt wreckers would be willing to wait a week before destroying stuff. Wikipedia have a system like this, it means for 48 hours, users can't create new pages or edit "semi-protected"pages. This stops registrations just to spam, as people don't have the patience.
Changing IP is easier than changing underwear.bruce89 wrote:Ypu could even check the IP addressess of people registering, only allow an IP address to register once per day or somewthing.
-
- Engineer
- Posts: 40
- Joined: 15 May 2007 16:49
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
A hardware hash? Take things like cpu type/serial,hard drive type/serial,ram type/serial,etc and make a hash from it and register it to that account. No other account could have that hash.
-
- Engineer
- Posts: 52
- Joined: 08 Mar 2004 21:14
- Location: Sunderland UK
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
why not then look at a banning system based on a persons MAC address it's unique to each network adapter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MAC_address has more info on it. it takes a lot of work for someone to change that.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
Please read the supplied Wiki page properly as it will tell you that most OSes allow you to change the MAC address. Ergo... absolutely useless.Spaz O Mataz wrote:why not then look at a banning system based on a persons MAC address it's unique to each network adapter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MAC_address has more info on it. it takes a lot of work for someone to change that.
OpenTTD is opensource, so I can send any garbage I want to sent as cpu type/serial,hard drive type/serial,ram type/serial,etc. Ergo... absolutely useless.ThePenguin wrote:A hardware hash? Take things like cpu type/serial,hard drive type/serial,ram type/serial,etc and make a hash from it and register it to that account. No other account could have that hash.
-
- Engineer
- Posts: 52
- Joined: 08 Mar 2004 21:14
- Location: Sunderland UK
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
mmm didn't know that was told in a cisco networking class off the teacher. the only other thing would be to ban ip addresses or make it so everyone else in the game must agree to allowing that person join.
- athanasios
- Tycoon
- Posts: 3138
- Joined: 23 Jun 2005 00:09
- Contact:
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
If someone wants to cause trouble and has some experience, there is no way to stop him.
A guy went into NATO without even knowing the password to log in. Their encryption didn't bother him from going through their satellite.
A guy went into NATO without even knowing the password to log in. Their encryption didn't bother him from going through their satellite.
http://members.fortunecity.com/gamesart
"If no one is a fool I am also a fool." -The TTD maniac.
I prefer to be contacted through PMs. Thanks.
"If no one is a fool I am also a fool." -The TTD maniac.
I prefer to be contacted through PMs. Thanks.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
I disagree, at least it would discourage harmful users from vandalizing openttd games, as they would have to actually do something to regain access to the games...Rubidium wrote:Please read the supplied Wiki page properly as it will tell you that most OSes allow you to change the MAC address. Ergo... absolutely useless.
#################
- doktorhonig
- Tycoon
- Posts: 1104
- Joined: 22 Aug 2006 11:03
- Location: Austria
- Contact:
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
I'm also a victim of natasha. Actually I didn't use a password, because I have no problem, if people join and continue with my company. I'll use passwords from now on, it's better that way.
-
- Engineer
- Posts: 40
- Joined: 15 May 2007 16:49
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
Would it be possible to have a seperate exe that isn't under the open source license that the OpenTTD server communicates with for the the hardware hash? Not openttd? And that be a setting that some servers require.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
Problem remains that the open sourced binary still has to send the reply to the server, which... well can fairly easily be circumvented. The server has furthermore NO way to check whether the hash is actually correct. To do this it needs to do the hashing as is done in the closed sourced binary. So it can either call the binary with some parameters to get the hash. Problem of this is that the hash can then easily be facked as one can change the OTTD client to get the hash of some garbage data sent into the closed source binary.
Second problem is having such an application that works on ALL OSes we currently have *and* makes it possible to port OTTD easily to other platforms.
Second problem is having such an application that works on ALL OSes we currently have *and* makes it possible to port OTTD easily to other platforms.
Re: Multiplayer is a waste of time
No, because I use Linux.ThePenguin wrote:Would it be possible to have a seperate exe that isn't under the open source license that the OpenTTD server communicates with for the the hardware hash? Not openttd? And that be a setting that some servers require.
Seriously, the options proposed here seem sound. The arguement that the source code is GPL meaning anyone can see it and so circumvent any hashing algolrithm is silly, as the people who do the vandalising probably don't know C++ (neither do I (thankfully)). They are obviously infantile idiots, so I don't think they have the skills to get the sourcecode let alone modify it and compile it.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: paulcobbaut and 8 guests