Question re: Copyright
Moderator: OpenTTD Developers
Question re: Copyright
Hey Guys,
Just looking over the discussions and thought this was a valid point.
Q: Are the creators planning on charging for this version of TTD?
If not, then isn't the copyright issue a moot point? The creators are acknowledging the original source of the game, mentioning they are recompiling it into a totally different language and are not charging for it.
Since they are not profiting from this venture, and therefore not profiting from recompiling Chris's original code in C, where is the issue? It's not as if people aren't being told who did the original programming. If Owen or Ludde (or any other people) were charging for this, and weren't paying any royalties to Chris Sawyer or the legit owners, then yes, I'd see a problem.
Anyone see my point?
Just looking over the discussions and thought this was a valid point.
Q: Are the creators planning on charging for this version of TTD?
If not, then isn't the copyright issue a moot point? The creators are acknowledging the original source of the game, mentioning they are recompiling it into a totally different language and are not charging for it.
Since they are not profiting from this venture, and therefore not profiting from recompiling Chris's original code in C, where is the issue? It's not as if people aren't being told who did the original programming. If Owen or Ludde (or any other people) were charging for this, and weren't paying any royalties to Chris Sawyer or the legit owners, then yes, I'd see a problem.
Anyone see my point?
Regards,
Dan MacKellar
================
Projects in Progress
North American Renewal Train Set Topic,Canadian Train Set Website, Canadian Train Set Development Topic, Finnish Train Set Website,Visit my Train Gifs Site
CN Boxcar drawn by Dave Hersrud
Dan MacKellar
================
Projects in Progress
North American Renewal Train Set Topic,Canadian Train Set Website, Canadian Train Set Development Topic, Finnish Train Set Website,Visit my Train Gifs Site
CN Boxcar drawn by Dave Hersrud
- DominionSpy
- Tycoon
- Posts: 1429
- Joined: 03 Oct 2003 23:59
- Location: Lancashire, UK
- Contact:
Re: Question re: Copyright
What about the other way round? Since there is a version which is free, then Chris is not profiting from it as he might have done otherwise.DanMacK wrote:Since they are not profiting from this venture, and therefore not profiting from recompiling Chris's original code in C, where is the issue?
...
Anyone see my point?
It's not enough to say that OpenTTD isn't making any profit.
You're saying I'm a Dominion spy, and don't even know it! - Dr. Bashir
That's the Joker in my avatar, not me. No wait it is me.
Yeah, I can see your point. I can also see the other way around, as dominionspy indicated.
A small, but vital point also: Copyright law isn't about profit, but rather ownership. Nowhere in copyright law have I seen any exceptions because of profit or lack thereof.
A small, but vital point also: Copyright law isn't about profit, but rather ownership. Nowhere in copyright law have I seen any exceptions because of profit or lack thereof.
"If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer. Let him step to the music he hears, however measured or far away" --Henry David Thoreau
Technically that's true, but the damages are assessed based on a.) revenues of the thief, and b.) foregone revenues of the actual owner. There aren't any revenues for OpenTTD so there goes that, and the game was discontinued ages ago so there goes the other. There are no damages to anyone, so there is nothing for the court to adjudicate. Also, there is the issue of fair use vs. derivative work, which are in conflict and are very hairy to unwind. The copyright nazis don't want you even to know there is such a thing as fair use, but there is whether they like it or not. It's based on two issues as I recall - a.) the percentage of the original work you used, and b.) whether what you made from it is clearly a new and different work. The only thing from TTD that OpenTTD uses, is the graphics; as a total volume that's a fairly low percentage. It would be good to not do that, and I imagine fairly soon that will be the case. Once the graphics are gone and the name is changed, all that's left is the idea, which is a whole lot harder to argue over. In order for anyone to prove that OpenTTD copied the TTD source code, they'd have to prove we had access to the source code, which as far as I know has never been the case (if it was, the Patch would have been so much easier...) And once OpenTTD has absorbed all the Patch improvements and new graphics, it will very clearly be a new and original work.CobraA1 wrote:Yeah, I can see your point. I can also see the other way around, as dominionspy indicated.
A small, but vital point also: Copyright law isn't about profit, but rather ownership. Nowhere in copyright law have I seen any exceptions because of profit or lack thereof.
So in conclusion, OpenTTD as it now stands is in a marginally risky position, but this will soon cease to be an issue if OpenTTD develops as we expect. Of course, this is a theoretic risk, it is exceedingly unlikely anyone would want to waste the money on an international lawsuit for a game of uncertain ownership that has been discontinued against a freeware version that makes no money. There's no money in it anywhere, for anyone, not even enough to pay the lawyers. The only involved group not known not to own TTD, is Atari, and they weren't willing to spend the time to find out if they even owned it or not, much less litigate.
Development Projects Site:
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
Where did I hear that before ?Bart wrote:It's very easy... the default OpenTTD package should come with 100% custom graphics/sounds/etc... but, there should be a choice for people with TTD to insert the original graphics...
"Peace cannot be kept by force. It can only be achieved by understanding." - Albert Einstein
Wasn't there a linux port of a game (you need the original game cds) that was stoped because the company didn't like it? ...
TTDPatch dev in retirement ... Search a grf, try Grf Crawler 0.9 - now with even faster details view and new features...
Probably they wanted to charge for the linux port, that would be a lot more dicey because you would be making money off of their idea and game. If there is no profit being made, there are still restrictions but they are a lot more grey.
Actually, I don't know how important the strict legalities are. Let's face it, if somebody sues Josef, it doesn't matter if they don't have a legal leg to stand on; Josef has already lost because he would have to pay a lawyer, waste time in court, etc. etc. even if he was found Not Guilty as I would expect. I think the much more pertinent issue is, would anyone bother suing? And to me the answer is pretty firmly No.
Actually, I don't know how important the strict legalities are. Let's face it, if somebody sues Josef, it doesn't matter if they don't have a legal leg to stand on; Josef has already lost because he would have to pay a lawyer, waste time in court, etc. etc. even if he was found Not Guilty as I would expect. I think the much more pertinent issue is, would anyone bother suing? And to me the answer is pretty firmly No.
Development Projects Site:
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
The FreeCraft port was shut down by Blizzard because it looked too much like their Warcraft II game and it could handle the Warcraft II graphics, maps, music and sound. Quite obvious since it was a clone.
Anyway, they didn't like it for some stupid reason, also partly because the big resemblance in the two names.
There wasn't any charge for the Linux port at all, open source just like this one. Quite a stupid step if you ask me since you still needed the original data from the original CD to play the game so instead of costing blizzard money it would get more people to buy the game.
Anyway, they didn't like it for some stupid reason, also partly because the big resemblance in the two names.
There wasn't any charge for the Linux port at all, open source just like this one. Quite a stupid step if you ask me since you still needed the original data from the original CD to play the game so instead of costing blizzard money it would get more people to buy the game.
Protect the Banana
Yeah, clones aren't liked by pubilishers, but there are some expections , i.e. Broken Sword 2,5 that Revolution Software even supports
Maybe we could count on similar statement of Chris Sawyer and Atari
Maybe we could count on similar statement of Chris Sawyer and Atari
see my transportation photos on fotozajezdnia
No, impossible. Chris Sawyer has no legal standing, he has no ability to say anything. Atari won't even find out if they own the game, obviously they aren't going to say anything if they don't know they own it, and they aren't going to spend the time and money to find out if they own it, just to give it away. And since the game isn't being published anymore (OK, there may be a few copies still floating around, but Atari isn't selling any and getting any money), the argument of them making more money isnt' of value. I already tried that angle.RadekK wrote:Maybe we could count on similar statement of Chris Sawyer and Atari
Development Projects Site:
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
-
- Route Supervisor
- Posts: 439
- Joined: 09 Mar 2003 10:12
- Location: Schagen, The Netherlands
- Contact:
I don't expect him to reply to that.Dan wrote:Could anyone ask chris sawyer who owns the rights to TTD? If anyone knows it will be most likely that he does.
I know people have tried to contact him in the past, the only thing floats around here is that Chris doesn't like ttdpatch. One of the few things we know.
Mike,
If you look on his website it says Microprose. But of course that is very out of date now.
Development Projects Site:
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
http://www.as-st.com/ttd
Japan, American Transition, Planeset, and Project Generic Stations available there
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests