Page 2 of 2

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 22 Mar 2014 14:57
by Baldy's Boss
Brumi wrote:I found a small bug: the rail line is inaccessible from the depot.
bad depot.png
The AI does very well by the way :)
And if that depot WERE on road level,trains whose orders involved the right angle turn could get stuck there.

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 10 Apr 2014 05:14
by Baldy's Boss
Baldy's Boss wrote:This AI does fairly well against me,I buy out more successful incarnations...but it does tend to ignore the right angle turn prohibition,and traps its trains in depots in locations from which they can't proceed.

Just bought out the latest in the game I play most actively.It had 73 stations of which 35 were unconnected,and in cases had 3 or 4 by the same industry.Also some cases of linking track to platforms the long way around.
Found another problem or two...I am playing it in a game with NARS vehicles available,which it always builds in preference to the default set...but it tends to not attach the cabooses without which NARS freight trains can't stop.Also,it's building only electric tracks while building only steam engines?

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 10 Apr 2014 09:20
by Brumi
AFAIK AIs are not required to attach a caboose to the end of their trains. (handling engine/wagon compatibility is quite the nightmare anyway...) Does this really cause a problem with the AI?

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 10 Apr 2014 13:43
by Baldy's Boss
Brumi wrote:AFAIK AIs are not required to attach a caboose to the end of their trains. (handling engine/wagon compatibility is quite the nightmare anyway...) Does this really cause a problem with the AI?
Some of the trains were losing money,I found one moving at I think 1 mph after my company bought the Ai and sent it to a depot to get a caboose.I think they operate normally until they break down.

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 18 Apr 2014 16:43
by Tve4
There's a slight bug: the AI builds railroads that have no vehicles.

For example, I'm using "Useless Tracks" newgrf, it has planning tracks and lifted tracks (roadbed only). The AI chooses to build planning tracks since they are cheapest. However, those track types have no vehicles, so AI just spends his money to build completely inoperable lines.

AI should check that the track set has suitable vehiles available before building.

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 18 Apr 2014 19:08
by PikkaBird
Brumi wrote:AFAIK AIs are not required to attach a caboose to the end of their trains. (handling engine/wagon compatibility is quite the nightmare anyway...) Does this really cause a problem with the AI?
AIs are not required to have a caboose. When Baldy buys out the AI and AI trains becomes human-owned trains, on the other hand...

Just goes to show what a bad feature those cabooses are. ;)

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 26 Apr 2014 06:02
by Baldy's Boss
PikkaBird wrote:
Brumi wrote:AFAIK AIs are not required to attach a caboose to the end of their trains. (handling engine/wagon compatibility is quite the nightmare anyway...) Does this really cause a problem with the AI?
AIs are not required to have a caboose. When Baldy buys out the AI and AI trains becomes human-owned trains, on the other hand...

Just goes to show what a bad feature those cabooses are. ;)
And just which vehicles require brake vans?

Interesting that it builds the cheapest "Useless tracks"...it builds more expensive electrified tracks for its 1920s steam engines!

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 08 Sep 2014 21:17
by Kernigh
Here are more examples of bad depot placement.
First bad depot
First bad depot
fast-depot-1.png (74.91 KiB) Viewed 4974 times
FastPTPAI 4, OpenTTD 1.4.2. My company is red. I bought 50 trains, including this one, from a bankrupt FastPTPAI. This train wants to reach Kedhead Cross Mines, but can't leave the depot, because the depot has no connection to the sloped track. The industry at Kedhead Cross Mines has closed, so I am about to sell this train and demolish this station.
Second bad depot
Second bad depot
fast-depot-2.png (39.74 KiB) Viewed 4974 times
This is from an old game, perhaps an older FastPTPAI version. FastPTPAI is pink. There are two problems here. First, the depot has no track connection. Second, the depot is facing the wrong track! This train wants to reach Sedingwell Mines. If the depot faced the other way, the train would not be stuck there!

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 21 Apr 2016 16:56
by xarick
screenshot#6.png
screenshot#6.png (204.28 KiB) Viewed 4476 times
train can't unload coal at that station
autosave15.sav
(2.04 MiB) Downloaded 104 times

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 17 Sep 2016 11:17
by Kogut
2cc trainset has passenger-only monorail. This AI attempts to use it to move other cargo.

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 27 Dec 2017 15:49
by xarick
Excessive CPU usage in valuator function

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 23 Mar 2020 13:38
by odisseus
Is this project still active? The AI looks promising, but it has big trouble when it comes to building depots.
ai-fail-1.png
ai-fail-1.png (25.76 KiB) Viewed 3118 times
ai-fail-2.png
ai-fail-2.png (23.27 KiB) Viewed 3118 times

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 23 Mar 2020 21:20
by odisseus
Some routes are, well... suboptimal. However, this is a common problem for many different AIs.
ai-fail-3.png
ai-fail-3.png (48.53 KiB) Viewed 1088 times

Re: FastPTPAI

Posted: 01 Mar 2021 22:35
by Baldy's Boss
odisseus wrote: 23 Mar 2020 13:38 Is this project still active? The AI looks promising, but it has big trouble when it comes to building depots.ai-fail-1.pngai-fail-2.png
In my "Which AIs are now actively maintained?" topic this one was mentioned in 2015 as not updated in the past year and a half.
The programmer's most recent post was in 2018.