7of9: first of all, it looks very nice!
now some points of critique (constructive of course
* in the diagonal view(s), the locomotive looks a bit different from what it looks like in the horizontal view. It looks a little bit too short in my eyes and also the seperation line between the first "part" and the second "part" is not curved like in the horizontal view.
* also in the diagonal view the windows of the pax wagons look a bit "bumpy" - maybe you can cheat a bit on that by using an antialiasing technique (inbetween colors)
FooBar: i am amazed - the roof looks great
only something on the benches disturbs me... i don't know what it is, maybe the color or something... really i can't express what it is but i think something can still be improved on these benches. maybe you have an idea yourself, or someone else here? (anyone else agree with me?)
That is why I post the in-between-pics, becaust i want the consctructive critique. It is after all my 2nd sprite(set). After looked at the \ (and the / that is mainly a re-shadowed mirror) sprites a 2nd time with a few hours inbetween there is a diffrence that should be taken care of somehow. Either way, im dedicated to this(/theese) sprites to make it/them proper. I've played this game for <insert to many here> years, and i feel like I need and want to contribute to make somethings better, and when and/or if i can make this sprites proper, I can hopefully make more, and play the game with proper engines, livery overrides, and everythinge else! After all, I have always been a fan of the original trainset with the nice highspeed maglevs
To me it seems like the front window is somewhat off, and im not too sure if it is the _ view, or the / view(s) that should be delt with, but i will look into it tomorrow. Not it is 3am here, and i will watch an x-files episode before I (we (me and wife)) gets to sleep (season 4 episode 21 for thoose who cares). cheers
I'll perfect them (more) tomorrow, it seems like I improve/create sprites best in the morning
cheers *takes one more beer*